Geographical political ecology includes a large number of theoreticallyinformed, empirical studies in spatiallydelimited locales shaped by the interplay between local and extralocal processes. In 2004, michael watts and richard peet 2004 argued that political ecology as a field is nearly at the. Political ecology is the study of the intersection and relationship between the political, broadly understood, and environmental and ecological phenomena. Brookfield, 1987 and called for a regional political ecol ogy, which firmly joined political economy and. Political ecology an overview sciencedirect topics. But in the largest departure from my original effort, i have tried to stress that political ecology is not a method or a theory, nor even a single perspective. University of cambridge department of geography paper 3. Political ecology and environmental management in the loess. Emel and peet 1989 feature blaikie s 1985 political economic approach as it was used to describe the dynamics of soil erosion in developing countries.
Political ecology may be defined as the concerns of ecology and a broadly defined political economy blaikie and brookfield 1987, p. Naturesociety relationships are examined through an analysis of social forms of access and control over resources watts and. They start by noting that the etymology of the word degradation implies reduction to a lower rank. Political ecology is a highly dynamic research field within geographical studies on development. In the first, a theoretical approach to the problem of land degradation, regional political ecology blaikie and brookfield. The phrase political ecology combines the concerns of ecology. In doing so, they sought to understand the social, political and eco logical implications of this epochal transformation.
This document pdf may be used for research, teaching and private study. Aug 07, 2015 edited by piers blaikie, harold brookfield. Abstract the application of political ecology approaches to the study of land degradation since blaikie and brookfields 1987 book are notably scant in the academic literature. Coverpolitical ecology and the epistemology of social justice. This succinct definition has left room for discussion around what is political ecology a research agenda, an approach or a. Political ecology cambridge encyclopedia of anthropology. Some of this has to do with the growth of environmentalism since the 1960s, responding in particular to the effects of. Political ecology and the epistemology of social justice. Blaikie and brookfield 1987 with political ecologists maintaining a strong commitment to such treatments of climate vulnerability while maintain a skepticism toward hazards approaches e. Political ecology the political ecology approach, in its simplest definition, combines the concerns of ecology and a broadly defined political economy blaikie and brookfield, 1987, p.
Political ecology approach to island tourism planning and. In the company of fellow geographers susanna hecht, ben wis ner. Explaining political ecology and socialecological systems. Material analysis in the early days of political ecology, as outlined by blaikie and brookfield, was done through chains of explanation walker 2005. Blaikie and brookfield model have refined it and attacked it, but. Tom bassett, fikret berkes, piers blaikie, harold brookfield, judith carney, susanne freidberg, larry grossman, julie guthman, christian kull, tania li, nancy peluso, dianne rocheleau, joel. Subjects earth sciences, environment and sustainability, geography. Keywords indonesia, political ecology, political economy, poverty, soil conservation, terraces. Since blaikie and brookfield 1987 laid the foundations of the approach and formulated its first definition, the field has evolved in. Recent debates within political ecology have motivated serious reflection about key concepts and.
Together this encompasses the constantly shifting dialectic between society and landbased resources, and also within classes and groups within. In addition, the chain of explanation is a model that was created to characterize a technique used in the studies of political ecology by blaikie and brookfield evsp620, 2016. Rejecting apolitical or non political explanations that tend to blame overpopulation or land user practices for land degradation, this. In the late 1990s, political ecology was repatriated to anglophone countries, especially the usa and u. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. Combining political ecology and ecological disturbance theory. Conversations at the intersection of political ecology and science studies. This theory can be applied to analyse the interconnected local, regional. Political ecology geography bibliographies cite this for me.
Bryant and bailey 1997 chose to title their volume third world political ecology due to the fundamental socioenvironmental differences thought to exist between the global north and south. Political ecology has been important in explaining such phenomena, and particularly the social and political inequities both causing them and mediating their impacts bryant, 2015. Different actors, different perspectivespolitical ecology studies typically begin with a particular problem. Blaikie s legacy from this book was the beginnings of regional political ecology, a particular approach to understanding the economic and political drivers of resource degradation and particularly the lack of access to natural resources suffered by poor or marginalised people. Political ecology was, in its early stages, described as an interdisciplinary approach that combined the the concerns of ecology and a broadly defined political economy for understanding the ways in which land degradation and social marginalisation were interlinked blaikie and brookfield 1987. Brookfields interdependent development 1975 and blaikies the political economy of soil erosion in developing countries 1985. Definitions of political ecology authors definitions blaikie and brookfield 1987, 17 the phrase political ecology combines the concerns of ecology and a broadly defined political economy. Political ecology resets the analytical lens characteristic of earlier conservation and development planners and policy analysts to examine environmental transitions and perceived problems from indepth, historical and especially political perspectives blaikie, 1985. Political ecology critiqued its precursor, cultural ecology, as insufficiently attentive to the broader political and economic forces impacting on local humanenvironment interactions. The political ecology of jatropha plantations for biodiesel.
But it may be fair to say that the work of blaikie, 1985, blaikie and brookfield, 1987 did pioneer the analysis of environmental science and artifacts as politicized objects within political ecology, and to call this apolitical may be to suggest a divide between nature and society that many now question. Watts silent violence 1983 and piers blaikie and harold brookfields land. In a pioneering study, piers blaikie and harold brookfield 1987 address the issue of land degradation. The blackie brookfield anthology reveals that land there is also an interesting chapter on the need to degradation, i. Pdf land degradation and society piers blaikie, harold. Blaikie and brookfield understand human induced degradation as. Rangan and kull 2009 which conceptualized scale in spatial and socioeconomic categories such as local and global, individual and world in. The application of political ecology approaches to the study of land degradation since blaikie and brookfield s 1987 book are notably scant in the academic literature. Political ecology is a transdisciplinary research field addressing nature society interrelations, often with a focus on contentions and struggles over land and natural resources.
Political ecology is the study of the intersection and relationship between the political, broadly understood, and. In blaikie and brookfield 1987 the land managers are the central stage because of. An annual piers blaikie lecture on politics of the environment was begun at the university of east anglia in 2011. International handbook of political ecology ray bryant ed. Locating the political in political ecology anthropology, university. Political ecology is supposed to be a field of two parts of equal importance politics and ecology. Blaikie and brookfield identified key analy tical approaches in political ecology, including a focus on the ways the environmental actions of the land. Political ecology blaikie and brookfield s 1987 political ecology approach provided one of the early theoretical frameworks for this book.
Blaikie and brookfield describe political ecology in relation to land degradation, but the concept applies to caribou decline, an environmental resource that is degraded by a combination of natural and human causes. However, critics have pointed to the fact that it dwells on the politics, while rendering ecology. Political ecology is the study of the relationships between political, economic and social factors with environmental issues and changes. A political ecology of agricultural change in postsoviet. Power, knowledge and political ecology in the third world. In political ecology, hardly an article passes without the obligatory capdoffing citation of blaikie and brookfield s edited volume, and those by subsequent writers of political ecology textbooks like peet and watts 1996. A political ecology of jatropha plantations political ecology combines the concerns of ecology and a broadly defined political economy blaikie and brookfield 1987, 17. Blaikie and brookfield 1987 towards what has been described as progressive contextualisation bryant.
This work expanded the discussion of social contexts of environmen tal meaning begun in political economy of soil. The approach of regional political ecology describes the complexity of the. Piers blaikie s writings on political ecology in the 1980s represented a turning point in the generation of environmental knowledge for social justice. Course overview this course surveys key themes in the field of political ecology. Theoretical foundations and some background materials. A separate strand in the evolution of thirdworld political ecology relates to work on environmental topics in anthropology during the 1960s and 1970s. Countries, harold brookfield s and my land degradation and society, and bryant and baileys third world political ecology.
An example of a conceptual framework that exemplifies a link between ecological changes and political economic forces are displayed in figure i scoones, 1998. Rangan and kull 2009 which conceptualized scale in spatial and socioeconomic categories such as local and global, individual and world in a fixed hierarchy or. Pdf political ecology pe is concerned with how humans relate to the. If you have access to a journal via a society or association membership, please browse to your society journal, select an article to view, and follow the instructions in this box. Political ecology differs from apolitical ecological studies by politicizing environmental issues and phenomena. The applicability of political ecology to our study centers upon the ways that particular ideas about nature are mobilized for specific political and social ends marne, 2001. Pdf environmental problems and political ecology researchgate. Degradation and society blaikie and brookfield, 1987. Scholars inspired not ably by the work of butzer, blaikie, brookfield, turner and watts assessed the deepening human grip on biophysical processes. While political ecology can orient inquiry in varied circumstances, scholars have questioned its uncritical use in first world situations. In their foundational text, blaikie and brookfield 1987. The routledge handbook of political ecology speaking truth to. This is an open access document downloaded from orca, cardiff.
Political ecology thus encompasses the issues of the clash of individual interests and the potential for collusion that lie at the heart of political economy, and ecology s concerns with our biological and physical environment and emphases on holistic analysis that connects with the more social and powercentred field of political economy. Critical ecosystems as a concept in political ecology. The phrase political ecology combines the concerns of ecology and a. Political, economic, social, and cultural forces affect, and are affected by, ecological and environmental trends. Political ecology has proven to be a popular academic approach. Land degradation and society 1st edition piers blaikie harold. Link between ecological changes and political ecology by. Political ecology research and scientific innovation. Management, enterprise and politics in the development of the tropical rain forest lands 10. Early political ecological analyses were focused on landbased explanations of environmental change, focusing more on political control over natural resources and less on ecological processes eg, blaikie and brookfield, 1987. Since blaikie and brookfield 1987 laid the foundations of the approach and formulated its first definition, the field has evolved in many different directions among others, see blaikie 1999.
Political ecology geography bibliographies cite this. Blaikie and brookfield 1987 developed the political ecology framework known as chains of explanation for analysing the disparities associated with land degradation and the marginalisation in global south communities. The structural approach to political ecology emerged in the late 1970s and combined. Political ecology and the epistemology of social justice abstract piers blaikie s writings on political ecology in the 1980s represented a turning point in the generation of environmental knowledge for social justice. Mar 01, 2008 but it may be fair to say that the work of blaikie, 1985, blaikie and brookfield, 1987 did pioneer the analysis of environmental science and artifacts as politicized objects within political ecology, and to call this apolitical may be to suggest a divide between nature and society that many now question. Blaikie and brookfield 1987 defined political ecology as the combination of ecological concerns and a broadly defined political economy. Download pdf did you struggle to get access to this article. His writings since the 1980s demonstrated a further transition in.
1125 559 1577 1474 181 1264 362 955 1174 799 1026 1033 1075 1383 1465 1587 1090 1607 1282 1305 503 708 17 260 1515 250 14 251 876 892 1593